When a lake is more than just water...

True stories of the paranormal and unexplained of the Pymatuning Lake region of Western Pennsylvania and Eastern Ohio.

Click here to share your experience!

Trending Encounters...

All
History's Mysteries
Spirits & Ghosts
Strange Encounters
Unidentified Flying Objects
Wait What?
History's Mysteries
Christmas Ghost Stories
Tis the season for Christmas songs but that does not mean ghost stories cannot be told. In the classic song "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year" there is the line "...there will be be scary ghost stories..." What does that mean? Where ghost stories a Christmas tradition? What was the reason to tell...
Strange Encounters
A Shove in a Dark Kitchen
A Shove in a Dark Kitchen
Submitter: R.M. Subject: Strange Encounter Location: A family home in West Pymatuning area near...
Unidentified Flying Objects
Strange Lights Over Conneaut Lake
Strange Lights Over Conneaut Lake
Submitter: A. Cook Subject: Unidentified Flying Object Location: Conneaut Lake, Crawford County, PA 16316...
Spirits & Ghosts
Ghostly Woman in the Yard
Ghostly Woman in the Yard
Submitter: Dannielle Subject: Spirits & Ghosts Location: A house by Bigler Cemetery Greenville, PA...
History's Mysteries
Dead Woman Found In Pymatuning Swamp – Found Book Excerpt
Dead Woman Found In Pymatuning Swamp – Found Book Excerpt
Submitter: Paranormal Pymatuning Subject: History's Mysteries Location: Future Pymatuning Lake Paranormal Pymatuning's submission: This...

Commercial Break

Merchandise

Help keep the lights on... or off.

Read More

The Reading Room

Books of interest or of no interest.

Read More

The Other Realms

Items of the weird and more.

Read More

Commercial Break

What people are saying about us!

"When I need the latest lakeland paranormal news, I can rely on the Paranormal Pymatuning website to keep me informed and up to date!"
Joseph Sasquatch Esq.

Found something interesting ?

Pymatuning lake and the surrounding area
SEND US YOUR EXPERIENCES!​
Scroll to Top